The Federalist Society held its 2022 National Lawyers Convention on November 10 through November 12. The Convention panel videos are now available online, including one titled "Major Questions Doctrine: West Virginia v. EPA?" The panel, moderated by Judge Edith Jones of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, features Professors Jennifer Mascott and Thomas Merrill, as well as top-notch litigators Ian Gershengorn and Yaakov Roth. Like other events featuring commentary and analysis of the Supreme Court's 2020 decision in West Virginia v. EPA, the panelists discussed the case as a matter of textual interpretation and interpretative canons, in light of the non-delegation doctrine, in view of Chevron doctrine, and also in connection with the court's application of Chevron deference to agency determinations about the scope of their own jurisdiction in its 2013 decision in City of Arlington v. FCC.
One interesting point made by Mr. Gershengorn about 51-52 minutes into the panel and again at about the 1 hour 21 minute mark was that net neutrality regulation constitutes "the easiest major doctrines case you're going to see" because then-Judge Brett Kavanaugh decided that net neutrality is a major question in the D.C. Circuit in U.S. Telecom v. FCC.
FSF President Randolph May addressed the implications of West Virginia v. EPA for net neturality regulation in his July 2022 Perspectives from FSF Scholars, "A Major Ruling on Major Questions." And he pointed out that the court's opinion in West Virginina v. EPA actually quoted then-Judge Kavanaugh's 2017 opinion dissenting from denial of en banc review in U.S. Telecom v. FCC.
Posts
