FirstNet's Public Safety Communications Network Continues to Grow

On January 24, AT&T released its report for the fourth quarter of 2023. AT&T announced that the FirstNet nationwide public safety broadband network it constructed has increased its total connections to more than 5.5 million across 27,500 law enforcement and first responder agencies. FirstNet is overseen by FirstNet Authority, an agency within the NTIA.

The widespread adoption by law enforcement and first responder agencies of FirstNet and other enterprise networks is significant because it undermines the FCC's attempted partial rebranding of public utility regulation of residential mass-market retail broadband Internet access services as a vital public safety measure. The Commission's Notice proposing to reclassify broadband Internet access services as a public utility under Title II of the Communications Act even acknowledges that "much of the communications between public safety entities and first responders take advantage of enterprise-level dedicated public safety broadband services." Indeed, enterprise-level dedicated networks with quality-of-service guarantees are more ideally suited for government agencies such as emergency first responders. 

 

On December 14, 2023, the Free State Foundation filed public comments opposing Title II reclassification and imposition of public utility regulation on broadband Internet access services. FSF's comments called attention to the glaring disconnect between imposing public utility regulation on commercial broadband Internet access services in the name of national security and public safety when the military, law enforcement, and emergency responders rely heavily on dedicated networks. 

 

Also, in the Free State Foundation's reply comments, filed on January 17, 2024, we observed that "it is a weighty matter to impose government controls over private services and property catering to civilians in the name of national security and public safety." And thus, "[i]t is unlikely that Congress intended to alter the balance between public power and private rights through such an expansive reading of Title II." Our reply comments voiced agreement with the proposition that national security and public safety have never before been relied upon by the Commission as a justification for common carrier regulation of broadband.

 

For more on the empty national security and public safety rationale for regulating residential commercial broadband Internet services as public utilities, see FSF’s comments and reply comments. See also my October 2023 Perspectives from FSF Scholars, "Net Neutrality Regulation Is Not a Public Safety Measure."