On March 20, the FCC announced a slate of orders that reduced regulatory burdens for voice service providers seeking to retire old legacy copper networks. Chairman Brendan Carr and agency staff deserve credit for taking proactive steps to eliminate and reduce regulations that delay and run up the costs of making technology transitions to more advanced networks.
The FCC released four orders. The first order clarified the Commission's Adequate Replacement Test criteria for streamlining discontinuances of telecommunications services under Section 214(a), initially adopted in the 2016Technology Transitions Order. The agency found that the rules had been misunderstood in an overly expansive way as requiring pre-discontinuance network performance testing of replacement networks only according to a specific set of requirements. As a result, "there has been a significant delay in carriers availing themselves of the technology transitions streamlined discontinuance process for their own replacement services, to the detriment of consumers who have been slower to receive next-generation services than the Commission expected." Accordingly, the order states: "We thus clarify that a carrier seeking Commission authorization to discontinue a legacy voice service pursuant to the Adequate Replacement Test's totality of the circumstances with respect to its own replacement service need only show, based on the results of the carrier's routine internal testing or other types of network testing, that 'the network still provides substantially similar performance and availability' as the service being discontinued."
The agency's second order "waives the filing requirements in the Commission’s network change disclosure rules adopted under section 251(c)(5) of the Communications Act of 1934." In the order, the agency found that "good cause exists to waive any requirement to notify the Commission of network changes" by incumbent local exchange carriers (LECs) such as changes resulting from the retirement of copper networks and transitions to next-generation networks. "As a result, an incumbent [local exchange carrier] LEC now is only required to post public notice of its planned network changes through industry fora, industry publications, or on the carrier’s publicly accessible Internet site, and to provide direct notice to interconnected telephone exchange service providers for copper retirements and short-term network changes." And it found that the waiver’s benefits outweighed any costs given extraordinary developments in the market over the last 30 years – including the dramatic rise of VoIP services to over 75% of fixed retail voice subscriptions at the end of 2023, while switched access lines continue to dramatically decline.
Its third order waives Section 214(a) notice and application requirements for providers seeking to grandfather legacy services – that is, to stop offering those services to new customers.
Additionally, the agency's fourth order waives the "stand alone service" requirement in the Commission’s rules for service discontinuance established in the agency’s 2018 Wireline Infrastructure Order. By granting the waiver, the order provides relief that was requested in a February 2025 petition by USTelecom. According to the order, USTelecom has asserted that adults in landline-only households had fallen to 1.3% of all households, and that bundled voice and broadband options, are available at prices that compare favorably to legacy voice pricing.
In each of the copper retirement orders, the Commission found that relief from the regulatory requirements would free up the investment of resources in the development and deployment of more advanced communications services.
The release of the four copper retirement orders coincides with Chairman Carr's announcement of the opening of the Commission's DELETE, DELETE, DELETE initiative. Under new leadership, the Commission's early actions are hopeful indicators that the agency will modernize its rules and reduce old and wasteful requirements.
P.S. The reduction and modernization of the FCC's rules will be on the agenda for the Free State Foundation's Seventeenth Annual Policy Conference - #FSFConf17 - on Tuesday, March 25, in Washington D.C. Register online.
Posts
