PRESS RELEASE: The FCC's Public Interest Authority Is Not a Blank Check!

Regarding the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit’s decision issued today in Texas Association of Broadcasters v. FCC, Free State Foundation President Randolph May issued the following statement:

“For at least two decades now, in this law review article and otherwise, I have been urging the FCC, as a matter of bureaucratic self-restraint and regulatory modesty, to construe the congressional delegation of public interest authority narrowly. The Fifth Circuit’s decision holding that the FCC lacks authority under the 'public interest' standard to require broadcasters to collect and disclose, on a broadcaster-identifiable basis, certain employment data, including that based on race and gender, should be a cautionary tale. In holding the FCC’s regulation unlawful, the Court declared that 'the FCC’s authority to act in the ‘public interest' does not extend outside of the statutorily prescribed tasks that Congress has instructed the FCC to carry out.'

With a standard as concededly amorphous as 'the public interest,' regulators will always be tempted to deploy the delegation as a sword, as they were in this case. While Democrat FCC commissioners surely have been far more prone in the past to take an overly expansive view of the agency’s public interest authority, the temptation exists regardless of party. It should be resisted.

Here what I said in the Conclusion to my 2008 law review article:

With convergence and competition in the communications marketplace a reality, it is indeed time to revisit the application of the public interest standard. Whatever the merits of regulation under the indeterminate standard in the earlier, more monopolistic analog age (and I have serious doubts), the exercise of such unbridled and malleable discretion by the FCC is no longer appropriate in today’s digital environment. Assessments of marketplace competition primarily should guide the Commission’s regulatory decisions. Absent Congress’s or the courts’ narrowing the agency’s public interest authority, which is unlikely, the Commission, uncharacteristically, should heed my modest plea for regulatory modesty. In an exercise of self-restraint, the FCC should commit itself to narrowing the application of its public interest authority."