Foreign Stream Ripping Operation Loses Big in U.S. District Court

On February 11, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia entered an order in UMG Recordings, Inc. v. Kurbanov, awarding copyright holders nearly $83 million in statutory damages against two of the world's most high-trafficked websites offering stream-ripping services. Plaintiff copyright owners also received an award of costs and statutory attorney fees, as well as a preliminary injunction against the stream-ripping operation. The respondent in the case owns stream-ripping websites that unlawfully convert copyrighted sound recordings into stored electronic files and makes copies downloadable by users across the world, including about 1.5 million users in Virginia. The websites generate ad revenues targeted to its large user base. 

The District Court's order from February 11 followed an October 2021 default judgment order, as well as a March 2021 order on remand from the Fourth Circuit in which the District Court concluded that its exercise of jurisdiction over the foreign website owner satisfied constitutional due process concerns. My blog post from June 2020 analyzed the Fourth Circuit's opinion that recognized the District Court's specific personal jurisdiction in the case. 

It may be very difficult for the copyright owners in in UMG Recordings, Inc. v. Kurbanov to collect on their judgment against the owner of the stream-ripping websites. But as explained in my June 2020 blog, the Fourth Circuit's decision may serve as a precedent that will bolster the prospects for copyright owners in pursuing civil justice against online piracy in future cases. 

Free State Foundation President Randolph May and I wrote about the importance of efforts to combat online copyright infringement, including by stream-ripping websites, in our June 2021 Perspectives from FSF Scholars, "Fighting Online Piracy Will Boost American Economy and Jobs."