Reps. Doyle and Latta Lay Out Plan to Reform Spectrum Management

Earlier today, on its "Congress Blog," The Hill published an op-ed penned jointly by Representatives Michael F. Doyle (D – PA) and Robert E. Latta (R – OH). Determined to avoid a repeat of the recent kerfuffle between the FCC and the FAA over 5G mobile operations in the C-Band, the two lawmakers set forth a four-element plan to overhaul interagency spectrum coordination processes.

As you undoubtedly recall, earlier this year the launch by Verizon and AT&T of 5G using C-Band spectrum licenses for which they contributed billions to the U.S. Treasury was impacted when, at the eleventh-hour, the FAA raised aviation-related concerns.

This occurred even though, prior to auctioning that spectrum, the FCC undertook a lengthy, deliberate, and engineering-informed process that considered, and addressed, potential interference.

Over the last few years, other disagreements regarding FCC efforts to repurpose high-value, underutilized spectrum similarly have played out in unprecedentedly high-profile fashion. They include the L-Band (vis-à-vis the Department of Defense), the 5.9 GHz band (the Department of Transportation), and the 24 GHz band (NASA and NOAA).

In "Aviation conflict highlights the need for spectrum management reform," Representative Doyle, Chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee's Subcommittee on Communications and Technology, and Representative Latta, its Ranking Member, expressed their well-founded concern that "declining faith in how these decisions are made is beginning to show signs of jeopardizing the consumer and economic benefits we've enjoyed for generations."

In response, the two laid out four principles that will guide their bipartisan efforts to "pursu[e] public oversight and restor[e] trust in the spectrum management process."

Those principles are as follows:

1. Reassert that it is NTIA that has the responsibility "to balance the needs and concerns of federal spectrum users, and to communicate those interests to its governmental counterparts and the public."
2. Promote "clear rules and expectations for federal and other spectrum users."
3. Ensure "that the government process for managing these critical spectrum resources [relies] on science and engineering …, not the institutional interests of a single federal agency."
4. Prioritize "the finality of [spectrum management] decisions."

Randolph J. May, the Free State Foundation's President, and Seth L. Cooper, its Director of Policy Studies and a Senior Fellow, made a number of similar points in "Congress Should Require Better Agency Coordination on Spectrum Policy," a February 15, 2022, Perspectives from FSF Scholars.

Specifically, Mr. May and Mr. Cooper (1) urged NTIA and the FCC to update their spectrum coordination Memorandum of Understanding to "expressly acknowledge NTIA's role in representing all executive branch agencies," (2) argued that "Congress should pass legislation to improve coordination among federal agencies," (3) noted with concern how the status quo "risks causing unnecessary delay and regulatory uncertainty," and (4) concluded that an improved process "could provide greater assurance to the public."