USTelecom Report: Broadband Value Proposition Steadily Improves

Released on Monday, the 2024 edition of USTelecom's annual report on the competitive broadband marketplace tells a familiar tale of falling prices and rising speeds.

Authored by Business Planning, Inc.'s Arthur Menko, "2024 Broadband Pricing Index: Broadband Prices Continue to Decline As Consumers Choose Faster Speeds" (2024 BPI) reveals that, accounting for inflation, the price of the most popular broadband speed tiers ("BPI-Speed") decreased by 9.4 percent between 2023 and 2024 while the price of faster tiers – that is, those at or near gigabit download speeds ("PBI-Gigabit") – fell by 3.9 percent.

Compared to 2015, BPI-Speed inflation-adjusted prices are 59.9 percent lower. BPI-Gigabit inflation-adjusted prices, meanwhile, have decreased 43 percent since 2017. Of course, context is key – and a look at broader economic trends only underscores the increasing affordability of broadband:

• In real dollars, the per-Mbps price of BPI-Speed offerings has fallen by 81.2 percent since 2015 – and as the overall cost of consumer goods and services grew by 32.2 percent, the nominal price of BPI-Speed offerings fell by 41 percent.
• In real dollars, the per-Mbps price of BPI-Gigabit offerings has fallen by 43 percent since 2017 – and as the overall cost of consumer goods and services grew by 27.5 percent, the nominal price of BPI-Gigabit offerings fell by 21.4 percent.

While prices are shrinking, speeds are accelerating. In terms of downloads, BPI-Speed offerings are more than twice as fast as in 2015: 301 Mbps versus 141 Mbps. Upload speeds similarly have increased, from 51 Mbps to 96 Mbps.

Free State Foundation scholars have summarized every BPI report released by USTelecom. Posts to the FSF Blog addressing previous versions are available here: 2023 | 2022 | 2021 | 2020.

USTelecom Report Shows Price Drops and Speed Increases for Broadband Services

On October 11, USTelecom released its "2023 Broadband Pricing Index." This latest edition of the BPI report found that prices for fixed wireline broadband services – DSL, cable, and fiber-to-the-home – declined between March 2022 and March 2023. According to the BPI Report, inflation-adjusted prices for providers' most popular broadband speed tier decreased by 18.1% and prices for their fastest speed tier option went down 6.5%. Additionally, between 2015 and 2023, inflation-adjusted prices for the most popular speed tier declined 54.7% and prices for the highest speed tier option dropped by 55.8%. 

Also, the BPI Report found that, between 2015 and 2023, "download speeds offered in the most popular tier increased by 141.5%, while upload speeds increased by nearly 285%" and that "[i]n the fastest-offered tier, download speeds increased by 117.1%, with upload speeds up by nearly 90%."

 

The BPI Report also shows Consumer Price Index (CPI) trends for broadband Internet services compared to other goods and services. Between 2015 and 2023, costs for consumer goods and services rose by 28%, according to CPI-U, but consumer prices for the most popular and the fastest speed options went down by 37% and 39%, respectively. 

 

The report relies on the FCC's Urban Rate Survey of the largest 14 wireline broadband providers that collectively serve 90% of all terrestrial fixed broadband services sold in the U.S. The 2023 BPI Report is available on USTelecom's website. FSF Senior Fellow Andrew Long wrote about the 2022 BPI Report in a June 2022 blog post and about the 2021 BPI Report in a May 2021 blog post. 

 

The findings of the BPI Report are particularly significant now that the FCC has opened its Safeguarding and Securing the Open Internet proceeding and proposed to subject broadband Internet access services to public utility regulation. The continuing improvements in network speeds and the consumer-friendly pricing trends on broadband service plans are strong indicators that the broadband marketplace is competitive. Certainly, these market developments do not justify imposing stringent new regulation on broadband services. The Commission should not impose public utility regulation on broadband networks but maintain its market-oriented framework that has helped promote the private investment in competitive wireline broadband networks. For more on this point, see Free State Foundation President Randolph May's September 21, 2023, Perspectives from FSF Scholars, "Reimposing Burdensome Net Neutrality Mandates Will Harm Consumers."

2022 USTelecom Broadband Pricing Report: Further Proof that Competition Is Benefiting Consumers

On Wednesday, USTelecom | The Broadband Association released its third annual Broadband Pricing Index (BPI) Report. Once again, the facts demonstrate that competition between broadband service providers is benefiting consumers through ever-higher speeds and – critically, given rising costs overall – steadily decreasing prices.

"2022 Broadband Pricing Index: A Comparative Analysis Showing Decreasing Prices and Increasing Value for U.S. Broadband Service Over Time" (2022 BPI Report) focuses on two types of broadband service tiers – the most popular and the highest speed – and compares their average prices and speeds in 2020 to those from (1)  the year prior, and (2) 2015.

According to the 2022 BPI Report, over the last twelve months, prices for goods and services generally grew 8 percent. By contrast, the average cost of the most-popular tier, adjusted for inflation, fell 14.7 percent, from $42.59 to $36.33. The average price of the highest-speed tier, adjusted for inflation, decreased by 11.6 percent, from $65.78 to $58.12.

Since 2015, inflation-adjusted prices have plummeted 44.6 percent, from $65.62 to $36.33, for the most popular tier and 52.7 percent, from $122.94 to $58.12, for the highest-speed tier.

Meanwhile, average speeds for both tiers increased dramatically between 2015 and 2022:

• Download speeds for the most-popular tier grew 127.7 percent, from 43 megabits per second (Mbps) to 98 Mbps;
• Upload speeds for the most-popular tier expanded at nearly twice that rate: 249.3 percent, from 13 Mbps to 44 Mbps;
• Download speeds for the highest-speed tier increased 84.6 percent, from 141 Mbps to 259 Mbps; and
• Upload speeds for the highest-speed tier increased 107 percent, from 51 Mbps to 103.7 Mbps.

The full 2022 BPI Report is available here, an overview here. For summaries of, and links to, the first two reports, please check out these posts to the FSF Blog: 2021 BPI Report and 2020 BPI Report.