Showing posts with label COVID-19. Show all posts
Showing posts with label COVID-19. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 26, 2024

Media Advisory: Supreme Court Wrongly Lets Stand the Government's Coercion of Social Media

Regarding the Supreme Court’s decision today in Murthy v. Missouri, Free State Foundation President Randolph May issued the following statement:

The majority opinion seems strained in holding that the states and individuals complaining about social media censorship lacked standing. And Justice Alito's dissenting opinion is convincing regarding the merits of the First Amendment claim. By virtue of its very detailed — and chilling — description of the government’s ongoing interactions with Facebook and other leading social media companies, Justice Alito shows that the Biden Administration crossed the line from offering its suggestions regarding the removal of speech it disfavored to threatening retribution if the disfavored speech was not removed. Private entities are free to carry or not carry whatever speech they choose, but when government actions rise to the level of entangled coercion of private entities that they did in this case, then the government violates the First Amendment by suppressing the free speech rights of those censored.

Thursday, June 22, 2023

GOP Senators to Biden: Use COVID-19 Dollars to Extend ACP

According to Light Reading and other news outlets, on Tuesday a group of 8 Republican Senators identified for President Biden a stopgap funding source for the Affordable Connectivity Program (ACP): untapped COVID-19 relief money.

The ACP, which provides eligible households with a $30 monthly subsidy ($75 on Tribal lands) to apply toward their choice of broadband service and up to $100 for a connected device, was created by the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021 (IIJA). Congress filled the ACP's coffers with $14.2 billion on a one-time basis.

Without question, $14.2 billion is a hefty sum. However, given that (1) to date nearly 19 million households have signed up for the ACP, and (2) the FCC continues to encourage consumer participation through outreach grants, that money soon will run out – perhaps as early as the first quarter of 2024.

Accordingly, many have called upon Congress to appropriate additional funds to extend the ACP's lifespan. That group includes Free State Foundation President Randolph May, who urged Congress to "extend it, while mending it" in a Real Clear Markets op-ed published in April of this year.

And in a March 2023 Perspectives from FSF Scholars, Mr. May wrote that:

Congress should extend the worthwhile ACP program promptly by appropriating additional funding. At the same time, it can consider revising the program to better target the ACP benefit to those lower-income households most truly in need and adopting measures to minimize, to the extent possible, any waste, fraud, and abuse in the program.

Notably, the ACP has bipartisan support. In written testimony submitted prior to her participation in an oversight hearing held yesterday by the House Energy and Commerce Committee's Communications and Technology Subcommittee, FCC Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel wrote that "I strongly support funding the Affordable Connectivity Program into the future to help more families get and stay connected to the high- speed internet they need to participate in modern life."

Speaking during that hearing, Chairwoman Rosenworcel reportedly stated that:

As a result of the bipartisan infrastructure law, we've got lots of funds to help with the deployment in largely rural areas, but we're also going to need funds and efforts to address affordability. ACP is the best program we have ever developed to do that, and we've got to make sure it continues.

Earlier this week, Senator Roger Wicker (MS) and 7 of his Republican colleagues reportedly wrote to President Biden to share a novel short-term solution: "repurpose a portion of unobligated emergency COVID relief funds to ensure the continuity of funding for this program, while we explore alternative sustainable funding mechanisms and updated parameters."

Senator Wicker's coauthors include Mike Crapo (ID), Kevin Cramer (ND), Thom Tillis (NC), Shelley Moore Capito (WV), J.D. Vance (OH), James Risch (ID), and Todd Young (IN).

As did Chairwoman Rosenworcel in her House testimony, the letter's signatories emphasized the interdependent relationship between (1) the hundreds of billions in federal subsidy dollars, including the $42.45 Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) Program, targeting broadband infrastructure expansion, and (2) the ability of lower-income Americans to pay for the service that that massive public investment makes possible.

Specifically, they pointed out that, as those subsidized networks "become operational, the significance of the Affordable Connectivity Program will become even more important as it ensures our constituents can benefit from these historic investments in connectivity."

In response, a White House spokesman stated that "[w]e look forward to working with members of both parties to extend funding for the program so that it can keep lowering high-speed internet costs for tens of millions of American families."

Thursday, March 18, 2021

Report: Global Online Video Service Subscriptions Grew 26 Percent in 2020 to 1.1 Billion

The Motion Picture Association today released a report on the theatrical and home/mobile entertainment market.

It highlights the dramatic increase in subscriptions to online video services during 2020, the year of the pandemic.

Some additional data points:

  • Global online video service subscriptions broke the one-billion barrier for the first time.
  • Worldwide subscriptions totaled 1.1 billion in 2020, a year-to-year increase of 26 percent.
  • Subscriptions in the U.S. alone exceeded 308 million, a 32 percent increase from 2019.
  • Global revenues for home/mobile entertainment (that is, content released digitally and on disc) grew by 23 percent, to nearly $69 billion.
  • A higher portion of surveyed American adults – 55 percent – reported consuming more content online than the 46 percent who indicated they had watched more pay TV.
  • Over 85 percent of those between the ages of 2 and 17 reported that they watched full-length TV shows or movies on a mobile device.

The "2020 THEME Report" is available here.

Tuesday, February 23, 2021

Online Piracy Poses Substantial Malware Threat to Employer Networks via Remote Access

Digital Citizens Alliance, a nonprofit focused on the threats consumers face on the Internet, has releasedresearch survey highlighting a disturbing connection between online piracy, working from home, and employer network security threats.

As a consequence of the COVID-19 pandemic, millions of Americans are working remotely. When employees allow piracy devices and apps to access their home Internet connections, they open the door to malware attacks.

Alarmingly, it appears that a significant number of consumers do just that: 1 in 5 of those surveyed admitted to visiting a piracy website, 1 in 10 to using a piracy device.

Home networks that include piracy devices, or other devices running piracy apps, are three times more likely to experience issues relating to malware, which in turn expose the employer networks that they are used to access to cybersecurity risks.

Such concerns are particularly troubling with respect to those employees remotely accessing systems upon which confidential or sensitive data is stored.

Fully half of the respondents with access to such information and piracy devices attached to their home networks had issues relating to malware during the previous 12 months. By contrast, less than 20 percent of those not using piracy devices reported malware infections.

Tuesday, February 02, 2021

Comcast Announces Additional Voluntary Steps to Promote Broadband Adoption, Remote Learning, and Digital Equity

Comcast launched its low-cost Internet Essentials program in 2011. Over the last decade, it has connected millions of eligible low-income families at the discounted price of $9.95 per month, provided tens of thousands of free laptops, and invested hundreds of millions to promote digital literacy.

The ongoing public health crisis has focused greater attention on digital divides, remote learning, and digital equity. Today Comcast announced additional voluntary efforts to address these concerns.

Comcast's Internet Essentials program arguably is the leading example of the broadband industry's commitment to make high-speed Internet access more affordable for low-income families, but there certainly are others.

Such programs have been highly successful. So successful, in fact, that Congress made sure to leverage them in the recently passed COVID-19 relief package.

As I described in a recent post to the Free State Foundation's blog, Congress has appropriated $3.2 billion to the FCC for an Emergency Broadband Benefit Program that will provide discounts on broadband service during the COVID-19 pandemic. In doing so, it directed the agency to automatically approve providers offering "an established program as of April 1, 2020, that is widely available and offers internet service offerings to eligible households and maintains verification processes that are sufficient to avoid fraud, waste, and abuse."

The additional actions that Comcast announced today "to help connect as many Americans to the Internet as possible and create new opportunities for underrepresented communities through the education, resources, and skills training they need to succeed in today’s digital economy" include:

  • Increasing, automatically and at no cost, Internet Essentials downstream speeds from 25 to 50 Mbps and upstream speeds to 5 Mbps for all new and existing customers on March 1;
  • Continuing to provide 60 days of free service to new Internet Essential customers through June 30, 2021;
  • Expanding its commitment to connect Lift Zones – safe spaces at Boys & Girls Clubs and other locations where students can access free Wi-Fi – to cover 1,000 locations by the end of 2021; and
  • Providing $3.5 million in grants to "help[] more people of color gain the education and critical workforce development skills needed to access career opportunities in media and technology" as part of its $40 million pledge in 2020 to invest in partners focused on education and digital equity. Current recipients include CodePath, Genesys Works, Jobs for the Future, NPower, i.c. stars, Opportunity at Work, Goodwill Industries International, YWCA, and Philadelphia Youth Network.
As I highlighted in a May 2020 Perspectives from FSF Scholars, Comcast and other broadband providers didn't merely sign on to then-Chairman Pai's Keep Americans Connected pledge; many elected to go above and beyond the specific commitments – not terminating service to those unable to pay as a result of the pandemic, waiving late fees, and opening Wi-Fi hotspots to all Americans – set forth therein.

Providing new Internet Essentials customers with 60 days of free service was just one of the steps Comcast took at that time. Others included increasing downstream speeds from 15 to 25 Mbps, providing two months of free service to university students, and suspending data limits.

Further details on Comcast's commitment to education and digital equity are available here.

Tuesday, January 05, 2021

FCC Seeks Input on COVID-19 Broadband Discount Program

As I noted in a recent post to the FSF Blog, the $900 billion COVID-19 relief package recently signed into law as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 includes $3.2 billion for an FCC-run Emergency Broadband Benefit Program (the Program).

The Program will reimburse participating broadband Internet service providers (ISPs) that offer discounts to eligible low-income households and those that have experienced financial hardship during the current public health crisis. The maximum amount of the discount on the standard rate is $50/month ($75/month on Tribal lands).

In addition, ISPs can receive a one-time payment, up to $100, for making available a subsidized connected device (tablet, laptop, or desktop).

The Program will run until six months after the end of the pandemic or the $3.2 billion in funding has been depleted, whichever comes first.

On January 4, 2021, the Commission publicized the release by the Wireline Competition Bureau of a Public Notice seeking comment on how best to administer the Program. It seeks input on a number of topics, including ISP, household, service, and device eligibility; expedited approval of ISP applications; the reimbursement process; awareness promotion; and auditing, enforcement, and reporting requirements.

Comments are due on January 25 and reply comments on February 16.

Saturday, December 26, 2020

A Primer: The COVID Relief Bill's Broadband Funding Provisions

The 900 billion COVID relief and government funding bill passed by the House and Senate and now signed by President Trump includes nearly $7 billion for broadband-related initiatives. On the whole, the broadband funding provisions will promote more ubiquitous deployment of secure high-speed broadband services, especially to geographic areas and to individuals where access currently lags.

Areas of focus include an emergency discount on broadband Internet access service for low-income and economically impacted households, funding to "rip and replace" insecure communications network equipment, broadband deployment grants for Tribal lands and unserved areas, additional money for telehealth, and much-needed funds for updated broadband coverage maps, a topic of recent focus by the Free State Foundation.

Here's a recap of the broadband provisions.

In order to limit the allocation of scarce government resources to those areas in fact unserved, accurate broadband coverage maps are essential. Congress and the FCC are in agreement that currently available maps are not up to the task, and both have taken steps to address this issue, the former through passage of the Broadband Deployment Accuracy and Technological Availability (DATA) Act, the latter through the establishment of the Digital Opportunity Data Collection (DODC).

The DODC will utilize "granular and detailed coverage data" from Internet service providers (ISPs), along with input from government entities and the general public, to produce maps far more accurate than those that rely upon census-block-based information submitted via FCC Form 477.

However, As Free State Foundation President Randolph May and I noted in "Congress Should Fund Needed Broadband Maps This Session," a recent Perspectives from FSF Scholars, the money required to fund that effort until now had not been appropriated. This legislation provides the FCC with the full amount requested by Chairman Ajit Pai: $65 million.

The relief package also includes $3.2 billion to keep Americans connected during the COVID-19 pandemic. Eligible households will receive a monthly emergency broadband benefit in the form of a $50 discount on high-speed Internet access service. Eligibility generally is limited to low-income households and those who have endured lay-offs or furloughs.

As the administering entity, the FCC has sixty days to adopt rules implementing the program, which will continue for six months after the Secretary of Health and Human Services has declared an end to the public health emergency. The Commission will reimburse participating ISPs directly for the amount of the monthly discount and up to $100 for a connected device (tablet, laptop, or desktop computer) that they provide. A provider need not be designated as an Eligible Telecommunications Carrier in order to participate.

In addition, the legislation tasks NTIA with disbursing a total of $1.3 billion for broadband grant programs, $1 billion targeting Tribal lands and $300 million for unserved (including rural) areas. Recipients of Tribal Broadband Connectivity Grants may use those funds to deploy fixed broadband infrastructure in unserved areas or, during the pandemic, for subsidized broadband service, distance learning, or telehealth programs.

The remaining $300 million will be made available in the form of Broadband Infrastructure Deployment Grants, which will target unserved areas for network infrastructure construction and prioritize, among other things, projects that target smaller communities (that is, counties, cities, or towns with less than 50,000 inhabitants).

NTIA also will become home to a new Office of Minority Broadband Initiatives that will perform a number of responsibilities, most significantly the administration of a $285 million pilot program focusing primarily on the broadband needs of Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) and their surrounding communities.

Congress addressed another funding need, relating to potential security vulnerabilities in telecommunications equipment manufactured by Chinese companies Huawei and ZTE currently deployed in U.S. networks, by allocating up to $1.9 billion to "rip and replace" those devices with trusted alternatives. In March 2020, lawmakers passed the Secure and Trusted Communications Networks Act of 2019, which banned recipients of Universal Service Fund support from purchasing at-risk equipment and services, mandated that they remove such devices from their networks, and directed the FCC to establish a program to reimburse primarily smaller providers (that is, those with fewer than 2 million customers) for replacement equipment.

In November, the Commission adopted rules and procedures to implement that legislation, but Congress had not yet appropriated the money required. The relief package funds this effort and expands the pool of recipient providers to those with up to 10 million customers – though it prioritizes those with less than 2 million customers.

In addition, the relief package provides the FCC with just under $250 million in additional funding for its COVID-19 Telehealth Program established earlier this year by the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act.

Finally, the bill incorporates (1) the December 31, 2021, deadline for the FCC to commence an auction of the 3.45-3.55 GHz band established by the Beat CHINA for 5G Act, and (2) the repeal of the mandate to auction the T-Band – spectrum that first responders depend upon for mission-critical communications in a number of large cities – set forth in the Don't Break Up the T-Band Act of 2020.

In a statement, FCC Chairman Pai "applaud[ed] Congress for including ... a number of provisions that advance critical national priorities in communications policy" and "salute[d] Congressional leaders for working together in a bipartisan manner to reach agreement on this consequential legislation that will help protect our national security, close the digital divide, advance telehealth, and promote American leadership in 5G."

Monday, December 21, 2020

Wi-Fi Alliance Releases Report Highlighting Critical Role of Wireless Networks During COVID-19 Pandemic

2020 was a banner year for unlicensed spectrum. For the first time in decades, the FCC made available significant amounts of additional capacity for Wi-Fi. The Wi-Fi Alliance recently released a report that affirms the wisdom of those actions.

Long before the COVID-19 pandemic motivated many Americans to learn, work, seek treatment, and interact socially from the safety of their homes, Wi-Fi had started to outgrow unlicensed allocations in the 2.4 and 5 GHz bands. The exploding number of connected devices and ever-evolving requirements – higher speeds, lower latency – demanded not just more spectrum, but also contiguous wideband (160 MHz) channels able to take full advantage of Wi-Fi 6, the latest iteration of the technical standard.

The Commission responded in April by freeing up 1,200 MHz in the 6 GHz band for unlicensed use. I wrote in a February 2020 Perspectives from FSF Scholars about the potential of Wi-Fi 6 equipment operating in the 6 GHz band – branded commercially as "Wi-Fi 6E" devices – to modernize wireless networking.

In addition, in November the agency reallocated 45 MHz of spectrum in the 5.9 GHz band to unlicensed use. The Free State Foundation filed comments supporting that proposal, and I wrote a supporting piece, "The FCC's 5.9 GHz Proposal Would Advance Both Wi-Fi and Vehicle Safety," shortly before its adoption.

In a December 7 statement announcing the agency's approval of the first Wi-Fi 6E device, Chairman Ajit Pai highlighted the role that Wi-Fi has played during the current public health crisis and proclaimed a new era in wireless connectivity:

Today, we get an exciting glimpse of America's Wi-Fi future.... During the COVID-19 pandemic, we've all seen how Wi-Fi has enabled everything from work-at-home to telehealth to remote learning to streaming and gaming. Wi-Fi 6 will turbocharge each of these and more, and will also complement commercial 5G networks. Bottom line: The American consumer's wireless experience is about to be transformed for the better.

A December 2020 report prepared by Telecom Advisory Services LLC and released by the Wi-Fi Alliance quantifies just how important Wi-Fi networks are during these trying times. A few key takeaways:

  • Global Wi-Fi use has increased roughly 82 percent during the pandemic.
  • U.S. smartphone use of Wi-Fi increased over 10 percent in March.
  • The number of devices connected to Wi-Fi networks has increased by 11 percent.
  • The number of simultaneously connected devices has jumped at least 60 percent.

Thursday, September 24, 2020

USTelecom Report on Broadband Documents Price Reductions, Speed Increases

USTelecom – The Broadband Association recently released a report comparing 2015 broadband pricing and speeds to those available today. "2020 Broadband Pricing Index: An Analysis of Decreasing Prices and Increasing Value for Broadband Service Over Time," as its name suggests, finds that "Americans are paying less today for broadband services that are significantly more capable than they were five years ago."

A few highlights:
  • The price of the most popular broadband service tier is 20.2 percent lower in 2020 than it was in 2015 – and 28.1 percent lower when inflation is taken into account.
  • Savings are even greater for the highest-speed tier: 37.7 percent (and 43.9 percent when inflation is considered).
  • Speeds, meanwhile, have increased, by 15.7 percent for the most popular offering and 27.7 percent for the highest-speed offering.

All of this is made possible by the $70-80 billion that providers invest annually in broadband infrastructure.

And while these statistics make plain that broadband is far more affordable than in the past, USTelecom at the same time acknowledges that there is more work to be done by government and private stakeholders to remove obstacles to adoption.

As I noted in a previous post, USTelecom is a partner in the "K-12 Bridge to Broadband" initiative, which works with school districts to identify, and connect at discounted rates, the 30 percent of students who lack the connectivity necessary to participate in remote learning during the COVID-19 pandemic.

The full report, authored by Arthur Menko, founder, Telcodata and Business Planning, Inc., is available here.


Friday, September 11, 2020

Cable Industry Expands Distance Learning Support with "K-12 Bridge to Broadband"

As part of the cable industry's commitment to support of distance learning, NCTA – The Internet & Television Association (NCTA), in conjunction with EducationSuperHighway (ESH), yesterday announced the "K-12 Bridge to Broadband" public-private initiative to increase home connectivity opportunities for students during the COVID-19 pandemic. USTelecom and NTCA also are partners in this effort.

According to ESH, a national non-profit, nearly 10 million students, half of whom are of color, lack Internet access. As a result, they risk falling behind as schools, in response to the health risks posed by the novel coronavirus, shift in part or entirely to distance-learning models. The goal of "K-12 Bridge to Broadband," therefore, is to "identify and potentially connect students in low-income families, enabling more students to participate in remote or hybrid learning."

In a press release, FCC Chairman Ajit Pai "thank[ed] NCTA and the EducationSuperHighway for launching this initiative to make it easier for students in low-income families to connect to the Internet."

"K-12 Bridge to Broadband" builds upon, and expands nationwide, recent successful partnerships between cable operators and school districts in cities that include Chicago, Atlanta, Philadelphia, Las Vegas, and Des Moines.

Pursuant to the announced framework of core principles, participating cable broadband providers will:

  • Create a “sponsored” service offering that school districts can purchase at a discounted rate on behalf of low-income students;
  • Work with school districts to identify students lacking access while also protecting participant privacy and the confidentiality of provider records;
  • Agree to a baseline set of eligibility standards that covers, at a minimum, households with students participating in the federal Free and Reduced Lunch program;
  • Minimize the amount of information families must provide in order to maximize adoption; and
  • Agree not to use school-provided information for the targeted marketing of unrelated services.

The "K-12 Bridge to Broadband" builds upon existing cable industry efforts to support distance learning, which include:

Friday, May 22, 2020

Congress Urged to Provide Stay Connected Vouchers to Impacted Americans

As of May 14, over 750 broadband providers and trade associations have signed on to the FCC’s Keep Americans Connected Pledge. In addition, many have gone above and beyond those commitment by, for example: temporarily suspending data caps and overage charges; offering free or discounted service to students, educators, and front-line medical personnel; and waiving charges for low-income households enrolled in the Lifeline program. In a May 13 FSF Perspectives, I provided numerous examples of the voluntary actions ISPs have taken.

However, the COVID-19 pandemic will continue to impact countless Americans financially for the foreseeable future. In a blog post earlier this week, I described a provision in the HEROES Act passed by the House of Representatives on May 15 that would make nearly $9 billion available to the FCC to reimburse eligible providers offering discounted service (up to $50 per month) and devices (up to $100) to eligible consumers for the duration of this crisis and six months thereafter.


Another proposal would provide Stay Connected Vouchers directly to consumers. Described by Steven Berry, President and Chief Executive Officer of the Competitive Carriers Association, in testimony before the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation on May 13, Stay Connected Vouchers would enable affected households to continue accessing essential communications services without amassing high account balances.

Broadband providers that adopt the Keep Americans Connected Pledge agree not to terminate service, and waive late fees, for those unable to make payments due to the novel coronavirus. But those payments are postponed, not erased. At some point in the future payment will be required. The Commission has extended through the end of June the period of time during which Pledge commitments apply, and that provides substantial short-term relief. But the fact remains that the longer this situation goes on, the greater the deferred financial obligation will be for affected individuals.

Stay Connected Vouchers would address this issue by establishing a longer-term safety net. Eligible households would receive two $50 vouchers each month during the COVID-19 crisis. Recipients could use them to pay for whatever communications service(s) they choose: text, voice, video, mobile or fixed broadband. Vouchers would expire six months after the end of the public-health emergency.

Proponents claim that a primary benefit of the Stay Connected Voucher program, which would be administered by the FCC, is its focus on practical and administrative expediency: by leveraging eligibility criteria and distribution mechanisms already in use for stimulus payments under the CARES Act, it would allow consumers to receive relief quickly.

Tuesday, May 19, 2020

FCC, House Pursue Different Approaches to Keeping Americans Online

Americans continue to suffer the economic consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic. Both the FCC and the House of Representatives recently took steps to prevent those struggling to pay their bills from being forced offline. The former did so via a renewed appeal for voluntary action. The latter passed legislation imposing specific obligations and establishing a reimbursement program for providers of discounted service.

May 13 FSF Perspectives describes how, on March 13, FCC Chairman Ajit Pai called upon the broadband industry to take the Keep Americans Connected Pledge. ISPs and trade associations that agreed to do so committed to maintaining service for those impacted financially by the novel coronavirus, waiving late fees, and allowing members of the public to access their Wi-Fi hotspots.


The time period covered by that pledge originally was to end on May 12. However, on April 30 the Commission extended it through the end of June. On May 14, it announced that a total of 774 broadband and telephone providers were on board. After the FCC concluded that additional relief was appropriate, the number of signatories went up, not down.

Meanwhile, on May 15, the House passed the Health and Economic Recovery Omnibus Emergency Solutions (HEROES) Act, which now awaits consideration by the Senate. Section 130401 of that bill converts the voluntary commitments solicited by the FCC into legal requirements that would remain in effect for the duration of this public health emergency.

It also prohibits broadband ISPs from enforcing data caps and charging for overages. Though beyond the scope of the Keep Americans Connected Pledge, a number of providers already had elected to take these additional steps, actions approvingly acknowledged by the Commission.

However, another provision of the HEROES Act, Section 130301, does create an $8.8 billion Emergency Broadband Connectivity Fund to provide reimbursements to eligible providers offering discounted service. Notably and explicitly, eligible providers need not be designated as eligible telecommunications carriers (ETCs) under Section 214(e) of the Communications Act.

Section 130301 directs the FCC to establish, within seven days of enactment (that is, without first conducting a notice-and-comment rulemaking), a program by which eligible households would receive a monthly discount of up to $50 on Internet service for the duration of the current crisis. The Commission would reimburse eligible providers for providing that discount, as well as up to $100 for supplying a laptop, desktop PC, or tablet

Eligible households are those that include at least one consumer who: meets the qualifications to participate in the Lifeline program, has been approved to receive free or reduced price breakfast or lunch at school, or has experienced a verifiable and substantial loss of income during since February 29.

Reimbursable monthly discounts would be made available for the duration of the COVID-19 public health emergency and six months thereafter.

Tuesday, May 12, 2020

Senate Commerce Committee Members Introduce COVID-19 Privacy Bill

Contact tracing, which involves identifying those who have tested positive for COVID-19 and the people with whom they have interacted, may prove effective in minimizing the spread of the virus and enabling the safe reopening of America. It typically is a labor-intensive effort, but digital tools, such as mobile apps, seek to automate at least part of the process. Such efforts have achieved qualified success in other parts of the world, such as Singapore and South Korea. But the monitoring of citizen movement inevitably implicates personal privacy. Businesses developing contact-tracing technology, and now lawmakers, seek to mitigate that impact.

A number of companies are active in this space, both domestically and internationally. The most high-profile effort involves Apple and Google, rivals that provide the operating system software (iOS and Android, respectively) running on virtually all smartphones. Working together to make available Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) that leverage Bluetooth technology, they have indicated that privacy is a “primary goal.” To that end they recently announced measures, such as prohibiting the collection of GPS location data and allowing only public health officials to deploy apps that utilize those APIs, in response to privacy concerns that have been raised.



In addition, on May 7, five Republican members of the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation – Chairman Roger Wicker (MS), John Thune (SD), Deb Fischer (NE), Jerry Moran (KS), and Marsha Blackburn (TN)  introduced legislation that, according to the Press Release, is designed to “provide all Americans with more transparency, choice, and control over the collection and use of their personal health, device, geolocation, and proximity data” and “hold businesses accountable to consumers if they use personal data to fight the COVID-19 pandemic.”

Specifically, the COVID-19 Consumer Data Protection Act of 2020 (CCDPA) would regulate “covered data” collected and used to:
  • Track the spread, signs, or symptoms of COVID-19;
  • Measure compliance with social distancing guidelines and other requirements; and
  • Conduct contact tracing.
Covered data includes:
  • Precise geolocation data;
  • Proximity data;
  • A persistent identifier; and
  • Personal health information.
It does not include:
  • Aggregated data;
  • Business contact information;
  • De-identified data;
  • Employee screening data; and
  • Publicly available information.
Should the CCDPA become law, “covered entities,” among other things, would be required to:
  • Provide individuals with clear and transparent notice regarding how their data will be handled, to whom it will be transferred, and how long it will be retained;
  • Obtain “opt-in” consent before collecting or using that data;
  • Limit that collection to what reasonably is necessary;
  • Ensure that that data is accurate (and allow individuals to correct inaccurate data);
  • Implement appropriate data security policies and practices; and
  • Provide a means for those who do “opt-in” to “opt-out” at a later date.
Covered entities include those that collect, process, or transfer covered data and are:
  • Subject to the FTC's jurisdiction;
  • Common carriers (which would be exempt from Communications Act provisions and FCC rules, other than those relating to 911, in connection with activities covered by the CCDPA); and
  • Nonprofit organizations
Covered entities would be required to issue public transparency reports within 30 days of enactment and no less than every 60 days thereafter providing information on the number of individuals from whom data has been collected, the categories into which it falls, how it is used, and to whom it has been transferred.

The CCDPA would preempt state and local laws “related to the collection, processing, or transfer of covered data for a purpose described” therein and empower the FTC and state attorneys general to enforce its provisions.

The CCDPA would remain in effect only until the Secretary of Health and Human Services declares an end to this public health emergency. Covered entities would be required to delete or de-indentify all covered data at the end of the current crisis.

Thursday, April 23, 2020

FSF's Randolph May in Real Clear Markets: "A Tocquevillian View of Reinvigorating the United States"

On April 22, Real Clear Markets published an op-ed by Free State Foundation President Randolph May describing how America best can transcend the Coronavirus outbreak.

"A Tocquevillian View of Reinvigorating the United States" makes the case that, although government has a limited role to play, it is private associations and voluntary activity – quintessentially American concepts nineteenth-century political philosopher Alexis de Tocqueville characterized as "associations of a thousand other kinds" in his seminal work, Democracy in America (1831) – that hold the key to our nation's timely and complete recovery.

A brief synopsis cannot capture its full import. To read the essay in its entirety, please click here.

Wednesday, April 22, 2020

MPA's Response to COVID-19 Gathered Together

Here's a new Motion Picture Association webpage that contains info regarding all the ways the film, television, and streaming companies are responding to the COVID-19 crisis. There are lots of links to information regarding relief efforts, specific resources, and the like.

Definitely worth a look. And like so many other efforts of the private sector, thanks are in order for all the resources made available.

Tuesday, April 21, 2020

Study: Additional Spectrum for Wi-Fi Promises Economic Benefits

A recent study commissioned by WifiForward concludes that additional unlicensed spectrum could contribute nearly $200 billion to the U.S. economy.

In order to mitigate the COVID-19 public health crisis, government officials have taken significant steps to "flatten the curve." As a result, many business establishments deemed to be "non-essential" are closed. So, too, are schools. The ability to work and learn remotely mitigates the economic and social impact of these measures. In-home Wi-Fi networks operating in unlicensed spectrum make this possible by allowing consumers to connect multiple end-user devices – laptops, smartphones, tablets, etc.  to broadband facilities.



As a consequence, the use of both broadband and Wi-Fi has increased dramatically. NCTA – The Internet & Television Association reports that, since March 1, its cable operator members have witnessed a 20 percent increase in downstream traffic and a 34 percent increase in upstream traffic. Meanwhile, data released by Plume reveals that the number of Americans online at home during the day has increased 105 percent since January 29, from 22.6 to 46.2 million. The Free State Foundation can attest to this new reality, having conducted its first meeting by videoconference just a few days ago.

In a February 7 FSF Perspectives, I noted that, according to the Wi-Fi Alliance, Wi-Fi's global economic value in 2018 was nearly $2 trillion, of which 25 percent – $499 billion – was captured in the United States. In 2023, those numbers are expected to increase to $3.47 trillion and $993 billion, respectively.

A study released by WifiForward on April 13 predicts that additional Wi-Fi capacity could generate substantial economic gains. Specifically, it concludes that FCC proposals to allocate spectrum to unlicensed use in the 5.9 GHz and 6 GHz bands could contribute more than $183 billion to the U.S. economy over the next five years. This includes a $106 billion increase in Gross Domestic Product (GDP), $69 billion in producer surplus, and $8 billion in consumer surplus.

Thankfully, one day soon people will be able to return to their offices and schools. However, the long-term effects of the Coronavirus pandemic on how, and from where, people work and learn remain to be seen. One thing, though, is certain: Wi-Fi will continue to play an integral role.

The executive summary of the study by Dr. Raul Katz is available here.

Thursday, April 09, 2020

Chairman Pai Talks Rapid Responses to COVID-19 and More in New Teleforum

On April 3, FCC Chairman Ajit Pai participated in a "Capital Conversations" teleforum hosted by the Federalist Society on "The FCC and the COVID-19 Pandemic." Audio of that teleforum is now available to stream or download from the Federalist Society's website. In the teleforum, Chairman Pai gives a quick overview of the FCC's activities in responding to the flu pandemic, including the Commission's Keep Americans Connected Pledge and COVID-19 Telehealth Program. During the question-and-answer portion, Chairman Pai also addresses current communications policy topics ranging from the Restoring Internet Freedom Order and Mozilla v. FCC remand to spectrum proceedings such as C-Band, L-Band, and 6 GHZ. 

Wednesday, March 18, 2020

FCC Acts to Maintain Lifeline Enrollment

In an action I applaud, the FCC took action yesterday to ensure maintenance of Lifeline service for low-income persons during the COVID-19 outbreak. See the description below the FCC's action.

Acting on its own motion, the FCC’s Wireline Competition Bureau today temporarily waived for 60 days the requirements for recertification and reverification of Lifeline subscriber eligibility, as well as requirements affecting enrollment representatives working on behalf of Lifeline service providers.

“We find that, in light of the coronavirus pandemic and community efforts to slow its spread, requiring Lifeline subscribers to respond to recertification or reverification efforts over the next 60 days would be an unreasonable burden on low-income households. Because we recognize the importance of connectivity for all Americans during this pandemic, we do not believe that the public interest would be served by de-enrolling Lifeline subscribers who are unable to complete the recertification process or reverification process over the next 60 days. We will continue to monitor the situation to determine whether any additional waiver of these rules and deadlines is needed beyond the 60-day waiver period and will otherwise direct USAC [Universal Service Administrative Co.] to promptly send or re-send recertification and reverification notices, as needed, to subscribers impacted by the waiver at the end of the 60-day waiver period,” the bureau said in an order adopted today in WC docket 11-42.